Submitted by Sheldon Rampton on
The Gallup polling organization marked the sixth anniversary of the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks by publishing a thoughtful analysis challenging the assumption that "religious fanaticism fuels extremism and therefore replacing Muslims' worldview with Western liberalism is the path to victory against terrorism. ... As a starting point, Muslims do not hold a monopoly on extremist views. While 6% of Americans think attacks in which civilians are targets are 'completely justified,' in both Lebanon and Iran, this figure is 2%, and in Saudi Arabia, it's 4%. In Europe, Muslims in Paris and London were no more likely than were their counterparts in the general public to believe attacks on civilians are ever justified and at least as likely to reject violence, even for a 'noble cause.' After analyzing survey data representing more than 90% of the global Muslim population, Gallup found that despite widespread anti-American sentiment, only a small minority saw the 9/11 attacks as morally justified. Even more significant, there was no correlation between level of religiosity and extremism among respondents." Rather than religion, extremists are motivated by the belief that "occupation and U.S. domination" is threatening their societies. "The real difference between those who condone terrorist acts and all others is about politics, not piety," writes Dalia Mogahed.
Mutternich replied on Permalink
Speaking of framing...
As has been noted frequently, but with disappointingly little effect, that phrase "war on terror" is itself a consciously fashioned frame, and an extremely successful one.
If the effort to deal with terrorism is a war, that provides an excuse for all the things commonly done in wars, even war crimes. If the war is not against a specific enemy, just "terror," anyone you want to target is fair game.
And since those pesky terrorists can pop up anywhere, anytime, the war can go on forever and probably will. And because the phrase is just so darned easy to say, even people who know better keep on using it and reinforcing the frame nonetheless.
maryam346 replied on Permalink
The UK and USA are islamophobia that is the bottom line
Muslims will always be degraded, stigmatised made to compromise their faith in order to fit in and get jobs they want. Muslims are treated as second class citizens,
if they dare rebel they will be slandered, labelled as mad and bad.
Terrorism is is just an excuse to futher deprive muslims and make them feel like the underclass